Is AI replacing bookkeepers?

Hmm….good question…but no.

AI is such a big question that is always looming over every sector in our society. Will bookkeepers become obsolete with AI? How do I stay up with AI to keep ahead of the game?

But your finances are not a game that I am willing to play at. 

AI is a tool, not a replacement.

AI can streamline some aspects of bookkeeping. Undoubtedly, it will change the profession, but bookkeepers will always be needed.

Key Takeaways

  • Will bookkeepers become obsolete with AI? No, AI will likely streamline, but not replace small business bookkeepers.

  • Can I replace my bookkeeper with AI? Technically yes, but ill advised. A fully AI Bookkeeping company is a red flag because it likely means no oversight and not knowing to ask what you don’t know to ask. 

  • Can ChatGPT do my bookkeeping? Please don’t. You will be giving access to your financial records to a database that can use it how they’d like, it is not fully secure, and it is likely to hallucinate with incorrect information. 

Now you may be asking: Can I replace my bookkeeper with AI?

Now, here’s where things get a little tricky.

Technically, yes you can….But you 100% shouldn’t.

Some businesses will advertise AI powered bookkeeping services. But, while AI can be a tool used in bookkeeping, it is certainly not able to replace the expertise of a bookkeeper entirely.

Any service that is strictly AI-powered is bound to mess up the books, and you’ll have to pay an actual experienced bookkeeper to fix those issues. 

You know how all open AI chats have a little disclaimer at the bottom about how AI makes mistakes…yea. 

Do you really want those mistakes inside your financials with no oversight and no knowledge of how your financial data is being used/trained with?

When looking through a client's transactions, the QuickBooks AI wanted to make suggestions for how to categorize a new deposit: Cash App Christ.  

To me, this could mean that it is a religious donation or something similar, so I looked into it. The AI wanted to auto categorize this as a new vendor named Christ…

A few issues with this: 

1. You may be missing out on some donation tax exemptions if it is a religious donation.

2. If you didn’t have someone checking over this, you likely would have inaccurate reports for how much you paid Christ for his services this year. 

This is how I see AI working in bookkeeping day-to-day. The automations are helpful, but the AI needs oversight to prove accurate.

Learn more about how to automate bookkeeping for a small business here. 

It's appealing using AI to do all the things, I get it. 

You want to offload and this AI opportunity says that it can do just that with just the click of a button and no discovery calls and for cheaper (at least for now) of an actual bookkeeper.

There are certain things that I would absolutely give AI to do, like proofreading or making a TLDR for this article; but that doesn’t mean that I want to give it full access to exactly how my finances work and no oversight. 

You and your business need, and deserve, transparency when it comes to your small business bookkeeping. You need, and deserve, someone that understands your business, knows how to ask questions, and is willing to be a detective with your best interest at heart.

Can ChatGPT do my bookkeeping?

ChatGPT is a text-based software that is not able to do bookkeeping. It works on a prediction-based model, guessing what words should come next in a string of words. 

This is completely different from bookkeeping, which requires a holistic understanding of a business’s finances. 

Remember that AI and automation are different. Sure, there is some overlap with AI being used within automation, but they need to remain separate entities.

Automation is used in bookkeeping all the time. But artificial intelligence is something else altogether, and is much less developed. In the near future, the best uses of AI in bookkeeping will be in flagging unusual data points, and in reducing manual entry.

For example, if you scan a bank statement and upload it to QuickBooks, AI will do a fairly good job of reading the statement and extracting individual transactions from it. But this is not perfect, and you shouldn’t be overly reliant on it. 


AI also can’t answer questions that aren't asked directly. 

That is a problem because users don’t know what they don’t know. A human bookkeeper can give you important information based on experience and your unique situation within your field. Even if you never would have thought to ask them for that information, they will come to the table with that insight and advice. 

I had a client who had been using an AI “Bookkeeping” program. The client’s tax advisor told them that the reports were wrong and had to be redone, so they came to me. 

After doing an extensive clean up project, I sent them their financial reports, including their balance sheet. 

At that point the client asked me, “What is a balance sheet?” 

Maybe AI could explain what a balance sheet is if it were asked directly, but my client never knew to ask. 

So something as foundational as how to read a balance sheet was never covered by this “AI Bookkeeper”.

So, Is AI Replacing Bookkeepers?

I may be biased as a bookkeeper myself, but I just don’t see AI going into full on takeover mode.

AI is meant to be a tool that helps you go from A to B, but it shouldn’t be the end-all-be-all to the entire process. 

Progress while sacrificing efficiency, consistency, and security should always be met with at least a little skepticism.

AI will continue to evolve and be able to do more and more tasks, but when it comes to your small business bookkeeping, I’d recommend having a real-life bookkeeper that can walk you through the process so that you are still holding the reins when it comes to your finances. 

Want to explore your options with one of those Real-Life Bookkeepers?

Let’s connect and sort out what works best for you. 

Next
Next

How to choose accounting software for a service-based small business?